Pirates Bay Real Estate, Homes, Condos for Sale in Fernandina Beach, FL

POOL HOME IN FERNANDINA BEACH! Welcome to island living at it's finest! This 3 bedroom, 2 bath home is perfectly situated in one of Amelia Island's most sought after neighborhoods, offering the ideal blend of comfort, convenience, and coastal charm. Centrally located on the island, you'll enjoy easy access to the beautiful Atlantic Ocean, nearby shopping, restaurants, and all the amenities that make Amelia Island such a desirable place to call home. Designed for both entertaining and tranquil relaxation, the outdoor space is a true highlight. Step out back to discover your own inground pool---the ultimate centerpiece for hosting summer barbeques, cooling off on warm Florida afternoons, or lounging under the stars. Recent updates provide peace of mind and modern appeal, including a new roof, new skylights, and fresh interior and exterior paint, making this home truly move-in ready. This home offers the perfect combination of location, lifestyle, and value. Don't miss your chance to own a piece of paradise on beautiful Amelia Island! Some photographs have been virtually staged.

2628 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER THE AMELIA GROUP.

$690,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 116151 MLS

Experience coastal living at its finest in this beautifully renovated home located in the highly sought-after Pirates Bay neighborhood. Perfectly situated just minutes from the beach and historic downtown filled with charmings shops, restaurants,and local attractions, this home offer the ideal blend of luxury , convenience, and serenity. Completely updated with top-of -the -line finishes and exceptional attention to detail, every space has been thoughtfully designed to create a warm and elegant atmosphere. From the stunning interiors to the peaceful outdoor setting, this home truly move-in ready and made for relaxed costal living. Enjoy the freedom of no HOA while being only 20 minutes from Jacksonville International Airport, making travel effortless. Weather you are looking for a full-time residence or the perfect coastal retreat, this exceptional property delivers beauty, comfort, and an unbeatable location. Home Warranty offered with ‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌‌ purchase.

2490 Captain Hook Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of PINEYWOODS REALTY, LLC.

Selling Office: PINEYWOODS REALTY, LLC.

$490,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 114880 MLS

3 bedroom, 2 bath home offering 1,633 sq. ft. in the heart of Amelia Island with no HOA. Renovations were started but not completed, creating a unique opportunity to finish and customize to your taste. New cabinets and flooring are already purchased and included, currently stored in the garage. Located just minutes from the beaches and historic downtown Fernandina Beach. For the buyer who sees possibility where others see unfinished work—this is your chance to turn creative chaos into perfection.

2442 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of CHARLES W. LASSERRE REAL ESTATE, LLC.

Selling Office: AMELIA SUNRISE REALTY.

$660,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2129971 MLS

completely remodeled home in Fernandina Beach Florida. Less than a quarter mile from the beach close to all shopping, restaurants, hospitals and schools. Three bedrooms and two full bathrooms just under 1500 ft.² new windows, new doors, new kitchen cabinets, new bathrooms, painted inside and out, new deck, new roof, new front door, new toilets, new flooring. Fantastic neighborhood no HOA fees low maintenance Yard move in ready.

2330 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of BEYCOME OF FLORIDA LLC.

Selling Office: .

$650,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2122414 MLS

Location, Location, Location! Welcome home to this inviting 4-bedroom, 2-bath residence offering 1,951 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space. This home blends comfort, function, and timeless appeal—perfect for everyday living and entertaining alike. Step inside to discover vaulted ceilings that enhance the open, airy feel, complemented by engineered wood floors throughout the main living areas. A cozy wood-burning fireplace anchors the living space, while separate sitting and dining rooms provide flexible areas to relax or host guests. The primary bedroom features carpet, while tile flooring in the bathrooms and indoor laundry room adds durability and convenience. Enjoy peace of mind with some major updates already completed, including a metal roof (2012), water heater (2019), and a newly replaced HVAC system (Fall 2025). Outside, your private oasis awaits—a saltwater system pool with passive solar heating panels, all enclosed within a screened lanai, perfect for year-round enjoyment. The fenced yard, vinyl siding, and irrigation system add to the home's practicality and curb appeal. Additional highlights include an indoor laundry room, coat closet, and a layout designed for comfortable living. This well-maintained home offers the perfect balance of indoor charm and outdoor relaxationready for its next chapter.

2265 Captain Kidd Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of SUMMER HOUSE REALTY.

Selling Office: .

$650,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 114483 MLS

Location, Location, Location! Welcome home to this inviting 4-bedroom, 2-bath residence offering 1,951 sq ft of thoughtfully designed living space. This home blends comfort, function, and timeless appeal—perfect for everyday living and entertaining alike. Step inside to discover vaulted ceilings that enhance the open, airy feel, complemented by engineered wood floors throughout the main living areas. A cozy wood-burning fireplace anchors the living space, while separate sitting and dining rooms provide flexible areas to relax or host guests. The primary bedroom features carpet, while tile flooring in the bathrooms and indoor laundry room adds durability and convenience. Enjoy peace of mind with some major updates already completed, including a metal roof (2012), water heater (2019), and a newly replaced HVAC system (Fall 2025). Outside, your private oasis awaits—a saltwater system pool with passive solar heating panels, all enclosed within a screened lanai, perfect for year-round enjoyment. The fenced yard, vinyl siding, and irrigation system add to the home’s practicality and curb appeal. Additional highlights include an indoor laundry room, coat closet, and a layout designed for comfortable living. This well-maintained home offers the perfect balance of indoor charm and outdoor relaxation—ready for its next chapter.

2265 Captain Kidd Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of SUMMER HOUSE REALTY.

Selling Office: KELLER WILLIAMS REALTY / FB OFFICE.

$683,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 114172 MLS

Wait no longer to enjoy island living at its best! This 3 bds/2 bath beautifully completelyremodeled home, centrally located between the sandy white beaches and Historic downtown. The home is a mile or so from the beach, and 30 min to a major airport. The home was painted inside and out, and with a new Kitchen with stainless steel appliances. The Primary and secondary bath were completely renovated with gorgeous finishes. There is new flooring throughout the entire house. There is a wood burning fireplace , Vaulted ceilings with a beautiful beam. Epoxy flooring in screen lanai and garage, All new lighting and many more upgrades.

2564 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of PINEYWOODS REALTY, LLC.

Selling Office: NON-MEMBER.

$515,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2110691 MLS

Nestled in the heart of Fernandina Beach, 2552 Pirates Bay Dr is a beautifully updated 3-bed, 2-bath home offering coastal charm and modern convenience. The open-concept layout features vaulted ceilings and a renovated kitchen with stainless steel appliances. Enjoy Florida living on the spacious screened porch overlooking a partially fenced yard—ideal for pets or play. Located in an A-rated school district, this home is just a short walk or bike ride to the beach and minutes from top-rated restaurants and shopping. Recent upgrades include a new roof (2025), enhancing peace of mind. Whether you're seeking a primary residence or a beachside retreat, this gem delivers comfort, location, and lifestyle.

2552 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of WATSON REALTY CORP.

Selling Office: .

$515,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 113707 MLS

Nestled in the heart of Fernandina Beach, 2552 Pirates Bay Dr is a beautifully updated 3-bed, 2-bath home offering coastal charm and modern convenience. The open-concept layout features vaulted ceilings and a renovated kitchen with stainless steel appliances. Enjoy Florida living on the spacious screened porch overlooking a partially fenced yard—ideal for pets or play. Located in an A-rated school district, this home is just a short walk or bike ride to the beach and minutes from top-rated restaurants and shopping. Recent upgrades include a new roof (2025), enhancing peace of mind. Whether you're seeking a primary residence or a beachside retreat, this gem delivers comfort, location, and lifestyle.

2552 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of WATSON REALTY CORP..

Selling Office: CABANA LANE, INC..

$490,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 112913 MLS

Bring Your Vision to Life in Pirates Bay! Located in one of Amelia Island’s most sought after NON-HOA communities! Just a mile from the beach, shopping, and dining, this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers 2,129 square feet of potential on a spacious ¼+ acre lot. Inside, you'll find a true fixer-upper with great bones and endless possibilities. The home features an oversized Florida Room and an oversized screened porch, ideal for creating the indoor-outdoor lifestyle you’ve been dreaming of. Enjoy the freedom of no community fees, and take advantage of the 2-car garage and expansive backyard, plenty of room to add a pool, garden, or outdoor kitchen with firepit. Whether you're looking to renovate for yourself or invest in one of Amelia Island’s best located neighborhoods, this property, at this price and this square footage, is a rare find on Amelia Island!

2564 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 MILLER ELITE.

Selling Office: PINEYWOODS REALTY, LLC.

$499,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 112664 MLS

Seeking an island home that is an entertainers dream and only 5 minutes to the beach? This bright and airy 3 bed/2 bath home is located in the lush and beautiful Pirates Bay neighborhood in the heart of all that the island has to offer. Vaulted ceilings and skylights throughout offers bright light, while the fireplace in the living area offers that warm glow during chilly months. Then the WOW factor: enter the large Florida Room providing a Caribbean feel with the wood vaulted ceiling, 3 walls of windows and view to the serene landscaping. Flow out to the deck and fire pit area to enjoy the zen like backyard. Great for both entertaining or unwinding after a long day. Roof 2017, HVAC 2013, hurricane boards for windows, No HOA. Don't miss this awesome opportunity to own your special island retreat!

2490 Captain Hook Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of RECIPROCAL LISTINGS.

Selling Office: NON-MEMBER.

$499,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2092577 MLS

PRICE IMPROVEMENT! Your Island Oasis Awaits — Just 5 Minutes to the Beach Welcome to your dream island escape in the lush, tropical setting of Pirates Bay. This bright and breezy 3-bedroom, 2-bath home is the ultimate entertainer's paradise, combining open-concept charm with tranquil vibes. Step inside to soaring vaulted ceilings, natural skylights, and a cozy fireplace that sets the mood year-round. But the real showstopper? The expansive Florida Room — a Caribbean-inspired haven with wood-beamed ceilings, three walls of windows, and peaceful views of the lush, zen-like backyard. Flow seamlessly outdoors to the deck and fire pit area — perfect for hosting under the stars or simply unwinding in your own private sanctuary. Upgrades and Features: Roof replaced in 2017 HVAC installed in 2013 Hurricane boards for windows No HOA Tucked in the heart of the island, this rare find offers both serenity and convenience.

2490 Captain Hook Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of FLORIDA HOMES REALTY & MTG LLC.

Selling Office: .

$475,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 112547 MLS

Welcome to 2330 Pirates Bay Dr, a beautiful 3-bedroom, 2-bath home nestled in the heart of the sought-after Pirates Bay neighborhood. Known for its canopy of mature trees and cozy, welcoming atmosphere, Pirates Bay offers a tranquil setting just 0.7 miles from the beach and within easy walking or biking distance to several local restaurants. Plus, you're just 3 miles from Historic Downtown Fernandina Beach, where charming shops, waterfront dining, and community events await. This move-in ready home features 2025 updates including; a brand-new roof, completely updated plumbing, and a freshly redone sprawling back deck perfect for outdoor gatherings or peaceful mornings under the trees. Inside, enjoy a freshly painted interior that brings a bright, clean feel to the home’s warm and inviting layout. Whether you're looking for a primary residence or a coastal getaway, this home offers comfort, quality, and timeless charm. Don’t miss the chance to enjoy the best of island living—schedule your private tour today!

2330 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of CABANA LANE, INC..

Selling Office: NON-MEMBER.

$670,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 111124 MLS

Nestled on a peaceful cul-de-sac in the sought-after Pirates Bay neighborhood, this charming, well maintained, island home offers the perfect blend of privacy, space, and island living. Lovingly owned by only two families, this single-story, split floor plan residence features 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and 1,870 sq. ft. of temperature-controlled living space—plus an enclosed 318 sq. ft. Florida room (heat and air could be easily added) lined with windows, and offers a peaceful retreat to enjoy nature overlooking a stunning ¾-acre coastal hammock lot. Inside, the open floor plan features vaulted ceilings, hardwood flooring, and a bright, airy feel. French doors from the living area lead to the Florida room, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor connection. The galley-style kitchen, dining room, and breakfast nook offer open sightlines, making this home ideal for both relaxing and entertaining. The primary suite, located on one side of the home for privacy, includes French doors to the Florida room, two walk-in closets, and an ensuite with dual vanities, a soaking tub, and a walk-in shower. On the opposite side, two additional bedrooms and a full bath provide flexible living space—one with hardwood floors, perfect for a home office, and another with direct Florida room access. Set in a well-established neighborhood, this home combines privacy, space, and island charm, all within minutes of Amelia Island’s pristine beaches, parks, and historic downtown Fernandina Beach. Walk to restaurants, shopping and the beach. Excellent walking and biking area and no HOA in this community! Recent improvements include; a 2020 roof, 2023 water heater and a 2025 water softener.

2526 Captain Hook Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX FIRST COAST.

Selling Office: SUMMER HOUSE REALTY.

$515,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 110930 MLS

Enjoy living close to the beach, shopping, and restaurants in this great mid island neighborhood of Pirates Bay! This home on .67 of an acre is located on a quiet cul de sac! The home features 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, a spacious living area and a large deck that allows for outdoor enjoyment! There is a fire place that can be enjoyed when those cold nights sneak up on us! Tile is used throughout the home! Easy access to the beaches, Historic Downtown Fernandina Beach or The Ritz Carlton....Let's take a look today!

2272 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of CABANA LANE, INC..

Selling Office: PINEYWOODS REALTY, LLC.

$545,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 107615 MLS

Welcome to your dream island retreat in the coveted Pirates Bay neighborhood! Nestled in a private location backing onto the serene preserve and Eagans Creek, this home offers tranquility and natural beauty at its finest. Step inside and be greeted by a bright and airy atmosphere complemented by high ceilings and abundant natural light. The spacious primary bedroom and bath provide a relaxing sanctuary, while the lush landscaping outside adds to the peaceful ambiance. Enjoy the oversized outdoor living space, perfect for entertaining guests or simply unwinding amidst the picturesque surroundings. With all-tile floors, cleaning is a breeze, and the roof installed in 2017 ensures durability and peace of mind. This home is just a 5 minute drive to the pristine beaches of Amelia Island and 5 minutes to Publix. Explore nearby shopping and dining options, all within easy reach. Updates abound, including new appliances installed in 2022, ensuring modern comfort and functionality. NO HOA!

2368 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 MILLER ELITE.

Selling Office: CENTURY 21 MILLER ELITE.

$640,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 104199 MLS

TREASURE IN PIRATE'S BAY Newly renovated home tucked away in private cul-de-sac location backing up to a beautiful stand of live oaks. Just over a half mile from the beach access at Seaside Park by Sliders Oceanfront Restaurant & Tiki Bar. Oversized double garage with workspace. Extra large kitchen with flex area for office, extra living, or media. Huge 24 X 16 back deck built for outdoor living. Designer light fixtures. New metal roof. Smooth ceilings. Quartz countertops, tiled showers. No HOA fees. $10,000 towards closing costs, interest rate buy down, or additional upgrades.

2260 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of FLORIDA HOMES REALTY & MORTGAGE.

Selling Office: SUMMER HOUSE REALTY.

$545,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 105738 MLS

Experience island living at its finest, just steps away from the pristine beaches of Amelia Island and a stone’s throw to its historic district. Nestled on a lush corner lot adorned with graceful oaks, this charming home offers both tranquility and convenience. The fenced, low-maintenance yard provides a private retreat. Inside, discover a well-maintained gem with all major systems in great shape… no looming roof, a/c or hot H20 heater replacements needed. The open floorplan has vaulted ceilings and skylights bathing the space in natural light. A secluded screened-in sunroom with tiled flooring invites relaxation. The spacious 2-car garage comes with a built-in workshop and ample storage. Recent upgrades include new appliances, updated floors, fixtures, baths, and kitchen. Enjoy no HOA fees, and relish in the assurance of a high, dry parcel. This relaxing haven is mere minutes from beaches, shopping, medical facilities, and schools. Embrace a coastal lifestyle without compromise.

2487 Captain Hook Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 MILLER ELITE.

Selling Office: NON-MEMBER.

$540,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 106035 MLS

Welcome to this delightful 3-bed, 2-bath split-bedroom home in the heart of Amelia Island. The quiet neighborhood of Pirates Bay has NO HOA FEES, but still has a "neighborhood feel" that you are sure to fall in love with. The backyard, complete with lemon trees and a convenient shed, provides ample space for your enjoyment. This centrally located property offers an effortless commute to work, schools, healthcare facilities, supermarkets, and a plethora of exceptional dining options. Enjoy Downtown Fernandina and, most notably, the pristine beaches that are within WALKING DISTANCE of your home! Take this opportunity to start living the island life you have always wanted. Schedule your tour today!

2525 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of SUMMER HOUSE REALTY.

Selling Office: DJ & LINDSEY REAL ESTATE.

$545,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1247906 MLS

Experience island living at its finest, just steps away from the pristine beaches of Amelia Island and a stone's throw to its historic district. Nestled on a lush corner lot adorned with graceful oaks, this charming home offers both tranquility and convenience. The fenced, low-maintenance yard provides a private retreat. Inside, discover a well-maintained gem with all major systems in great shape... no looming roof, a/c or hot H20 heater replacements needed. The open floorplan has vaulted ceilings and skylights bathing the space in natural light. A secluded screened-in sunroom with tiled flooring invites relaxation. The spacious 2-car garage comes with a built-in workshop and ample storage. Recent upgrades include new appliances, updated floors, fixtures, baths, and kitchen. Enjoy no HOA or CDD fees, and relish in the assurance of a high, dry parcel. This relaxing haven is mere minutes from beaches, shopping, medical facilities, and schools. Embrace a coastal lifestyle without compromise. (Back on market due to buyers deciding to look in another state.)

2487 Captain Hook Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 MILLER ELITE LLC.

Selling Office: .

$540,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1252188 MLS

Welcome to this delightful 3-bed, 2-bath split-bedroom home in the heart of Amelia Island. The quiet neighborhood of Pirates Bay has NO HOA FEES, but still has a ''neighborhood feel'' that you are sure to fall in love with. The backyard, complete with lemon trees and a convenient shed, provides ample space for your enjoyment. This centrally located property offers an effortless commute to work, schools, healthcare facilities, supermarkets, and a plethora of exceptional dining options. Enjoy Downtown Fernandina and, most notably, the pristine beaches that are within WALKING DISTANCE of your home! Take this opportunity to start living the island life you have always wanted. Schedule your tour today!

2525 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of SUMMER HOUSE REALTY.

Selling Office: .

$640,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1222526 MLS

TREASURE IN PIRATE'S BAY Newly renovated home tucked away in private cul-de-sac location backing up to a beautiful stand of live oaks. Just over a half mile from the beach access at Seaside Park by Sliders Oceanfront Restaurant & Tiki Bar. Oversized double garage with workspace. Large kitchen with flex area for office, extra living, or media. Huge 24 X 16 back deck built for outdoor living. Designer light fixtures. New metal roof. Smooth ceilings. Quartz countertops, tiled showers. No HOA fees. $10,000 Seller credit towards closing costs, interest rate buy down, or additional upgrades.

2260 Pirates Bay Drive, Fernandina Beach

Listing courtesy of FLORIDA HOMES REALTY & MTG LLC.

Selling Office: .

Browse All Pirates Bay Properties for Sale

Pirates Bay Real Estate & Homes