Fleming Island FL MLS Search

View All Latest Fleming Island 3500+ Sq. Ft. Properties for Sale

$734,900
5 Beds 4 Baths 2155544 MLS
MOVE IN READY Welcome to 1852 Hickory Trace Dr, a beautifully updated and well maintained, 5-bedroom, 4-bath home nestled in the prestigious River Hills Reserve community, centrally located in the heart of Fleming Island. As you step into the welcoming foyer, with upgraded double entry doors, prepare to be enchanted by the spacious 11' ceilings, the abundance of natural light streaming through the windows, and the impeccable updates gracing every corner of this residence. Upon entering, you'll find the formal dining room, a convenient office space, and the gathering room, all seamlessly connected to the Florida room. The open floor plan seamlessly merges the family room and kitchen, creating an ideal space for both entertaining and everyday living. The kitchen boasts exquisite quartz countertop, upgraded white and gray wood cabinets, accented with crown molding, soft-close drawers and cabinets, as well as convenient features such as a Lazy Susan and deep drawers. The entire right wing of the house comprises the luxurious primary suite, showcasing a spacious bedroom measuring 14'x24', alongside a meticulously crafted bathroom. The primary bath boasts a separate garden tub and a renovated walk-in shower, complemented by double vanities offering ample storage space. For added privacy, there is a separate water closet, along with a linen closet and his and hers closets, ensuring both functionality and elegance. Across the home, you'll discover three more bedrooms and two bathrooms, while an upstairs suite offers flexibility for guests, multigenerational living, or a private studio. Each of the three guest bathrooms has been redesigned and updated with modern trends. Additional features include an expansive Florida room with picturesque views overlooking the 11th Tee. providing the perfect setting to relax and entertain. The backyard has a fire pit, and additional outdoor living space. Additional information on the Features and Upgrades located in the documents. Roof 2019 Water Heater 2025 Main HVAC 2024 Central Vacuum System

1852 Hickory Trace Drive, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of WATSON REALTY CORP.

$695,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 2147318 MLS
Black Creek of Eagle Harbor | Downstairs primary suite | Huge loft/flex space | 2024 roof | 2026 Brand New Water Heater | Extended Screened Lanai | Community Pool and Dock Nearby Set in Black Creek of Eagle Harbor, 2518 Country Side Dr offers 3,727 sq ft, 5 bedrooms, a dedicated office, huge loft-flex space , 3.5 baths, a 3-car garage, and a 0.27-acre lot in Fleming Island. Soaring ceilings and abundant natural light create an impressive sense of scale, while new LVP flooring adds a fresh, modern feel. The updated kitchen features granite countertops and brand-new stainless steel appliances with open flow for everyday living and entertaining. The main-level primary suite adds comfort and convenience, and the downstairs office works well as a flex room. Upstairs, 4 bedrooms surround a huge extended loft, ready for media, games, hobbies, or lounge space. Outside, enjoy a private screened paver patio with a newer hot tub and room to design an outdoor kitchen. Major updates include a 2024 roof and 2025 water heater. Eagle Harbor includes resort style amenities to include a championship golf course, Talons Restaurant, clubhouse, 3 resort style pools with splash pad and diving boards, tennis, pickleball, multiple parks, paths, docks and waterfront access. Enjoy endless community events and the convenience of Thunderbolt Elementary, Fleming Island Highschool, the YMCA, and Village Square Shopping Center all close by.

2518 Country Side Drive, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICES FLORIDA NETWORK REALTY.

Selling Office: .

$1,179,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 2139230 MLS
Luxurious executive pool home in the exclusive gated community of Pace Island, in the sought after neighborhood of Pace Gardens. Upgrades include travertine entry, designer gourmet kitchen with quartz countertops and Thermador stainless steel appliances. Gorgeous primary suite with updated primary bath with huge-walk in shower and marble countertops. No carpet in this home, only wide-plank wood floors, beautiful tile, and LVP in the upstairs bonus room. Beautiful covered lanai, summer kitchen, heated pool and spa all in a screened enclosure, plus a large outdoor patio with retractable awning and fire pit where you can watch the sunset over the lagoon. All 4.5 bathrooms updated. Tons of closet and storage space. Soaring overheight ceilings with extra wide crown molding. Enormous bonus room upstairs is perfect man cave or rec room for kids with its own full bathroom, kitchenette and a full-sized Murphy bed. In top-rated Fleming Island School District. Elegant formal dining room, spacious breakfast nook, breakfast bar and outdoor dining area provide a plethora of choices for dining and entertaining. This home is truly turnkey with loads of new features. Newer roof (fall 2019), 2 new AC units (2024 and 2025), plus recent addition of mini-split upstairs. New Bosch dishwasher. New water heater. Plantation shutters on virtually every window in the house. Exterior repainted April 2026. Most interior rooms, doors and trim also recently repainted. New epoxy floor in 3 car garage. New pool equipment (heater, filter, blower, automation). Beautifully landscaped. Exceptionally quiet and peaceful neighborhood with 24 hour guard-manned security gate. Pace Island community has 5 lighted clay tennis courts, a full-sized lap pool, a smaller community pool, a community dock on Doctor's Lake, a nature trail, playgrounds, pickleball courts (new!), and community basketball court and park. Great for cyclists: Black Creek bike trail leads right to Pace Island's main gate. Fleming Island provides numerous convenient shopping and dining options within 10 minutes. Washer and dryer included. Fridge in garage included.

1943 Rose Mallow Lane, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of FLORIDA HOMES REALTY & MTG LLC.

$875,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 2139286 MLS
Dive right into this custom-built pool home by JA Long in the heart of Fleming Island. Throughout the years, this exceptional residence has been carefully curated and meticulously maintained, and its recent upgrades are here to impress. As you drive up, the beautiful landscaping and expansive front design create a warm welcome, while the double wooden doors greet you into a home designed for comfort and lasting impressions. Thoughtfully designed for both everyday living and effortless entertaining, this home showcases abundant natural light, functional living spaces, and quality improvements that enhance both style and peace of mind. A striking ledge stone fireplace anchors the main living space serving as a beautiful focal point that adds warmth, character, and timeless appeal. Plantation shutters throughout enhance both elegance and functionality, offering privacy while complementing the home's refined design. The gourmet kitchen delivers both style and performance, featuring a stunning redesigned and remodeled center island with new countertops and updated appliances, including a refrigerator and dishwasher--perfectly suited for everyday living and entertaining alike. The living area seamlessly transitions outdoors through pocket sliding glass doors that fully retract into the wall, creating a true indoor-outdoor lifestyle and opening to your private backyard oasis. The thoughtfully designed main level includes a spacious owner's suite, a guest or mother-in-law suite, a cozy den, and a dedicated office that can easily function as a fifth bedroom. Upstairs, a generous bonus room is complemented by two private bedroom retreats, each featuring its own ensuite bath and loft space--ideal for multigenerational living, guests, or flexible family needs. Attention to detail is evident throughout, with custom finishes and functional upgrades enhancing everyday comfort. Custom closets have been installed in all bedrooms except the guest/in-law suite, while the entire first floor showcases new luxury vinyl plank flooring and fresh interior paint. Step outside to enjoy the expansive estate setting, featuring a large front and side yard, a newly added firepit area, and a fenced section perfect for pets or play. The private pool area creates the ultimate setting for relaxing weekends and hosting gatherings year-round. Residents enjoy the best of both worlds--access to Eagle Harbor's resort-style amenities, while this intimate community also offers its own neighborhood pool, playground, scenic walkways, and a private dock on Black Creek, perfect for fishing, kayaking, and embracing Florida's outdoor lifestyle. Situated perfectly with access to shopping, A-rated Fleming Island Schools and private schools, hospitals, sports group such as Lacrosse, football, soccer, baseball and more. Come and view the home and say yes to your new address.

2659 Country Side Drive, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of MOMENTUM REALTY.

Selling Office: .

$2,700,000
6 Beds 6 Baths 2136395 MLS
Where Luxury Meets the Water -- Lakeshore Drive North, Fleming Island Some homes are built. This one was reimagined -- from the ground up, to the water's edge, and every square foot in between. Set on nearly ¾ of an acre along one of the most coveted stretches of Lakeshore Drive North -- one of the largest lots on the road -- this 5,166-square-foot estate (7,000+ sq ft under roof) commands 133 feet of deep-water frontage on Doctors Inlet, with access to both the Intracoastal Waterway and the Atlantic Ocean. Whether you're casting off at dawn or watching the sun sink into the water from your own backyard, this property delivers a waterfront lifestyle that simply cannot be replicated. A $1.7 million renovation completed in 2024 spared nothing -- and the vision behind it was equally exceptional. Every interior space was thoughtfully designed by Michelle Walsh Designs, resulting in a home where sophistication and livability exist in perfect balance. The result is a residence where every surface, system, and detail has been elevated to the highest standard. Offered Fully Furnished This is a truly turnkey opportunity. The home is being offered fully furnished, curated exclusively with pieces from Bernhardt and Restoration Hardware -- two of the most respected names in luxury home furnishings. Move in, set down your bags, and begin living. On the Water The dock was built for serious boaters -- a $150,000 fully permitted extension featuring both a 30,000 lb and 40,000 lb boat lift, multi-slip configuration, and deep-water access that accommodates vessels most waterfront homes cannot. With dockage space for all your friends to come by boat, this isn't a dock. It's a private marina. And with direct access to the Atlantic Ocean, your cruising grounds are virtually limitless -- including arriving by boat to some of the area's best waterfront restaurants, making every dinner out an experience before you even arrive. The Home The open floor plan with six private bedrooms, six bathrooms, a dedicated private office, and three oversized garage spaces give this home the scale and flexibility that growing families and discerning buyers demand. Two fireplaces anchor the interior with warmth and character, while heated floors add a quiet layer of everyday luxury underfoot. The kitchen is anchored by a full suite of Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances -- the standard by which serious culinary spaces are measured. Smart Home & Outdoor Living A $150,000 Savant Smart Home System puts the entire property at your fingertips -- lighting, audio, thermostats, televisions, shades, and screens -- all unified and effortlessly controlled. Outside, a $30,000 marine-grade Coastal Source outdoor audio and lighting system transforms the grounds after dark. The outdoor living spaces are extraordinary in scale: a 6,000 sq ft illuminated paver driveway sets the arrival experience -- expansive enough to accommodate RV and boat parking with ease -- while 4,500 sq ft of sandblasted marble porch and pool deck frame the heated saltwater pool and spa. After a day on the water, rinse off in the custom outdoor shower, wrapped in Brazilian IPE hardwood and tucked within lush tropical landscaping that makes every moment feel like a private resort. Add a basketball court, and the backyard becomes a destination in itself. A Location That Completes the Picture Fleming Island's Lakeshore Drive North is one of Northeast Florida's most sought-after addresses -- and this lot's scale sets it apart from nearly every other property on the road. Top-rated, A-rated schools are minutes away, making this as practical for families as it is aspirational. Shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences are in close proximity -- and thanks to Fleming Island's golf cart-friendly character, many can be reached without ever getting in a car. For those who prefer to arrive in style, several of the area's best restaurants are accessible directly by boat, turning a night out into an adventure. Peace of Mind A whole-home generator ensures uninterrupted comfort regardless of conditions -- critical on the water in Northeast Florida. The Rarest Detail of All This property enjoys all the benefits of an HOA community -- maintained aesthetics, neighborhood standards, pride of ownership -- without the HOA fees or restrictions. Sunset views. Deep water access. No compromise. Opportunities like this on Lakeshore Drive North are extraordinarily rare. Schedule your private showing today. https://youtu.be/1vrArF7sCtA?si=m7v43x5dpmKwfoJO

2241 N Lakeshore Drive, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of THE WILKINS WAY.

Selling Office: .

$1,999,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 2134775 MLS
Discover the epitome of luxury waterfront living at 1317 South Shore Drive in the heart of Fleming Island. This stunning estate, meticulously gutted and completely renovated between 2025 and 2026 with high-end construction quality and exquisite finishes, offers an unparalleled blend of modern elegance and serene natural beauty. Nestled on a sprawling 1.71-acre lot with 100 feet of pristine water frontage along Doctors Lake, this property boasts breathtaking, unobstructed views that capture the essence of Florida's coastal charm. Step outside to your private oasis, featuring a sparkling pool, summer kitchen, a large balcony overlooking it all, and a dock with boathouse; ideal for boating enthusiasts or simply savoring sunsets over the water. Inside, the expansive 3,977 square feet of living space is designed for both comfort and sophistication. The open-concept layout includes 5 spacious bedrooms, plus a dedicated office and versatile flex rooms to suit your lifestyle needs. With 4.5 luxurious bathrooms, every detail has been thoughtfully curated. The heart of the home is the large gourmet kitchen, equipped with top-of-the-line appliances, custom cabinetry, and a convenient butler's pantry! Additional highlights include a generous 3-car garage for ample storage and convenience. This fully reimagined residence combines timeless appeal with contemporary upgrades, ensuring a turnkey experience in one of Fleming Island's most coveted locations. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise!

1317 South Shore Drive, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of CHRISTIE'S INTERNATIONAL REAL ESTATE FIRST COAST.

$820,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 2131991 MLS
Experience elevated waterfront living in one of NE Florida's most sought after communities.This luxury 4 bedroom 3.5 bath estate offers 3,612 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space on a private preserve lot with panoramic lake views.Inside find soaring ceilings, polished travertine flooring, and expansive windows that fill the home with natural light while showcasing serene water views.The gourmet kitchen features a Sub-Zero refrigerator, granite countertops, and a 36'' cooktop making it perfect for entertaining or everyday living.The elegant family room features a sleek tiled fireplace and built-in wet bar creating a gathering space for entertaining guests or relaxing with family. A first-floor primary suite provides convenience and privacy along with a spa-inspired bathroom. Upstairs are 3 spacious bedrooms 2 full baths and a versatile bonus room. Step outside to enjoy a covered summer kitchen & expansive paver patio designed for enjoying Florida's year round lifestyle The preserve backdrop ensures no rear neighbors, making this an exceptional option for buyers prioritizing privacy, nature views, and quiet cul-de-sac-style living.Residents enjoy access to Eagle Harbor's extensive amenities, including multiple swimming pools, tennis and pickleball courts, championship golf, parks, playgrounds, and miles of walking and biking trails--ideal for those seeking an active lifestyle community in Fleming Island. Boating and waterfront recreation are easily accessible via Doctor's Lake, with a resident boat ramp and storage available. Nature enthusiasts will also appreciate nearby Lick Skillet Nature Preserve, a scenic 22-acre setting for fishing, kayaking, and exploring Florida's natural beauty.This home offers the perfect blend of luxury finishes, waterfront views, preserve privacy, and amenity-rich community living.

2517 Sunny Creek Drive, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER VANGUARD REALTY.

Selling Office: .

$1,375,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 2123192 MLS
Welcome to luxury riverfront living at its finest! Nestled along the banks of the St. Johns River in Hibernia Plantation, this meticulously maintained 5-bedroom, 5-bathroom estate spans 5,775 square feet of elegant living space on a .64-acre lot. Every detail of this home has been thoughtfully designed for comfort, function, and timeless style. Step inside and experience a seamless blend of sophistication and warmth. The chef's kitchen is a culinary masterpiece, featuring high-end appliances, custom cabinetry, and a spacious island perfect for entertaining. The open-concept living areas are accentuated by soaring ceilings, rich finishes, and a gas-start fireplace that creates the perfect focal point for gatherings. Four of the five bedrooms offers its own private en suite bath, ensuring privacy and comfort for family and guests alike. The primary suite features serene river views, a spa-inspired bathroom, and generous walk-in closets. Enjoy Florida's beautiful climate on the expansive patio overlooking the river, an ideal space for outdoor dining or simply relaxing as the sun sets over the water. The three-car garage provides ample parking and storage space. Located in the highly sought-after Fleming Island community, this estate provides both tranquility and convenient access to top-rated schools, shopping, and dining. This is more than a homeit's a lifestyle on the water. Schedule your private tour today and experience the unparalleled charm of 1462 Kathleen Way. Full bank appraisal done December 2025 showing 1.6 Million in documents. All information pertaining to the property is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. Information to be verified by the Buyer. Be advised that cameras may exist recording audio and video inside/outside the property, such as ring doorbells. Photos are digitally enhanced and could be altered, please verify.

1462 Kathleen Way, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of DJ & LINDSEY REAL ESTATE.

Selling Office: .

$884,900
5 Beds 4 Baths 2118533 MLS
Stunning gated Pace Island remodeled custom Brick and Stucco Poimboeuf built home on over .6 acres tranquil lagoon estate lot. Roof, pool, kitchen cabinetry, flooring, and tubs remodeled less than 2 years ago.Dramatic stained glass entry straight into two story 22' volume multi trey ceiling Living Room displaying gleaning new hardwood floors, and gas Fireplace. Upgraded woodwork and crown moulding is fantastic, some appears to be 7 step. 10' ceilings most rooms with double trey ceilings. Wainscoting in elegant dining room to right of foyer and office/5th bedroom and two story living room feature new gleaning hardwood floors. You are immediately impressed with the upgrades and view of pool, lagoon and tranquil back yard. Master suite is huge, lighted over sized vanity with sitting area, separate tiled walk in shower, floor design in all 4 bathrooms. Upstairs bedroom, media/game room and Jack in Jill bath is perfect for mother n law suite. Far right bedroom has own bath walking closet. Upgraded light bright home with.massive amount of wood detail featuring new hardwood floors in LR, DR, Office//plus wood flooring in Family Rm. Knockout open kitchen and Family Rm, Gourmet Kitchen displays new Quartz countertops and Back Splash, Gas cook top, Double Oven, 26 cubit inch Refrigerator, extra quiet dishwasher, work Island and newly remodeled breakfast bar. New carpet throughout upstairs except Bonus Room. Upstairs BR 2 has it's own huge bonus/game room and Jack N Jill bath perfect for inlaws. 13x14 3rd Br connects to Jack N Jill Bath. Loft office area and then right 4th Bedroom with own Bath and walk in closet. 9x11 Storage/Mechanical Room has numerous possibilities. Newly remarcited 35 foot pool and spa fountain has a self cleaning feature. This stately remodeled home is a rare find especially since it was built by one of our elite custom builders Barry Poimboeuf on over .6 acre lagoon lot in gated Pace Island. Pace Island is a 24 hour security gated waterfront community featuring community dock out to Drs Lake, pool, tennis courts, and soccer field. Front Club House, massive pool and kiddie pool, tennis courts and walking/jogging trails front to back. Lakes and trails reveal a pleasant lifestyle only found in Pace Island.

1947 Rose Mallow Lane, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of LEE DANIELL REALTY, INC.

Selling Office: .

$1,157,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 2115424 MLS
Stunning 2023 home situated on a spacious 1.5-acre lot, just one house away from the scenic St Johns River. This residence features a carpet-free interior with neutral décor throughout. The gourmet kitchen boasts premium JennAir appliances, quartz countertops, and a double oven range with six gas burners and a griddle. Enjoy the impressive butler's pantry equipped with a beverage center, a second refrigerator, custom cabinetry, and built-in storage. A convenient stop & drop area with four bays is located by the garage entrance. The two-story family room showcases a 60'' electric fireplace, custom shelving, and specialized lighting. The primary suite is located on the first floor, offering a dream closet with built-ins, a walk-through shower with illuminated niches, three shower heads, and a luxurious soaking tub beneath a custom chandelier. There's also a hidden, keyed closet in the master suite for a future safe. -(continues in additonal remarks ) The spacious laundry room includes a window, cabinets, and countertops, while all bathrooms feature custom tile work. Step outside to the 964 sq. ft. covered lanai, which leads to the saltwater heated pool area with a striking black pebbled finish. The home is ready for a future outdoor kitchen. Please refer to the feature sheet in the documents for a complete list of custom details. See feature sheet for all bulleted features.

1483 Emalyn Estates Court, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER VANGUARD REALTY.

Selling Office: .

$1,055,000
5 Beds 5 Baths 2103211 MLS
Welcome to The Preserve in Eagle Harbor — a rare enclave of old-growth oak trees and stately homes on estate-sized lots, nestled within the renowned Eagle Harbor community and offering easy access to all its celebrated amenities. This 4,202-square-foot home boasts 5 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, multiple bonus spaces, and a large air-conditioned storage room — offering abundant space for a large or growing family, remote work, or serving as the hub for entertaining friends and loved ones. For those needing a home office, there are dedicated rooms both upstairs and downstairs, providing quiet, productive spaces with strong connectivity. A spacious bonus room offers endless possibilities — from a home gym to an entertainment lounge or a teen retreat. The gourmet kitchen opens to the living room, keeping you connected to the action while preparing meals. Step out the back door into your private portal to endless summers filled with family fun. A large, covered patio overlooks a stunning heated pool, complete with a hot tub and cascading waterfall. Beyond this tropical oasis on your 0.72-acre lot lies a shaded, canopied backyard with a playset, rope swing, and even a zip line. To top it off, you're within walking distance of the highly rated, Grade-A Fleming Island Elementary School. Schedule a tour today and discover how this extraordinary house can become your forever home.

1576 Sandy Springs Drive, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of COLDWELL BANKER VANGUARD REALTY.

Selling Office: .

$995,000
6 Beds 4 Baths 2097982 MLS
Come home to this stately home nestled within the trees adjacent to nature. Property is on a cul-de-sac. Lot is very private. Three car garage courtyard and Portico are enclosed by an electric gate with keypad. Custom touches abound. Upon entering you are met by a sweeping staircase, chandeliers, and extra large format tile flooring. The cook's kitchen has granite counters, tile backsplash, ample prep island, stainless steel appliances to include a large capacity 48'' refrigerator, 5 burner gas stovetop and wall oven. Adjacent to the kitchen is a butler's pantry and a walk-in pantry. The family room has double height ceilings open to second floor. A gas fireplace completes the opulence. Primary bedroom is on first floor as is one additional guest bedroom. Bathroom finishes are tile, granite and frameless glass enclosures. Upstairs you will find a study nook, loft area, four more bedrooms and a balcony. The sixth bedroom is currently being used as a theater room. The home has practical aspects as well to include great storage with multiple walk-in closets, laundry with a utility sink, security cameras inside and out, and a great flow. The outdoor space is extraordinary. It is an entertainers dream. It starts with a covered patio and extends to a multilevel pavered pool deck. There are many vignettes for outdoor relaxation. Roof is approximately four years old. Both HVAC units approximately 2 years old. Home has much to offer as does the community. Amenities include three community pools to include splash pads for little ones, golf club membership availability, tennis courts, pickle ball courts, a community restaurant, and community docks to enjoy the river.

2563 Ferntree Lane, Fleming Island

Listing courtesy of HERRON REAL ESTATE LLC.

Selling Office: .

Start Your Search
© 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. This data is up-to-date as of . For the most current information, contact Florida Coastal Team - LPT Realty.

3500+ Sq. Ft. Fleming Island Real Estate